-- Visual literacies are great at stimulating reader response, right?
- What did you learn in the doing?
- What more would you like to learn?
- Pedagogical Applications?
- What would I change/do differently/add/etc.?
I'm not sure I would change much, except for allowing for more drafting of the actual iMovies. Because I was afraid of losing my work, I tried to do a lot in one sitting, and save quickly to disc. "La Belle Dame" is the roughest poem, and the words go by rather quickly, but that kind of influences the reading I had of the poem, so it works as a second draft. "Mutability" is an experiment on transitions and images, and "To A Skylark" is my final perfection (if there is such a thing) of my skills. "Skylark" is much more structured, and shows my proficiency in developing a story in the images alone. It is also much longer (originally, I had it around 10 minutes, but I cut it down to around 8, which was a test of my editing skills). I think I would have begun my website sooner. It was sort of an afterthought, and I worked on it relentlessly for a couple of days, but the informative sections, about the Romantics and the time period, need to be comprehensive and (somehow) interactive. I had thought about a WebQuest, but wasn't sure exactly where to start with it. I will think about it more over break.
- Comments and Concerns
Though I know I vented to a couple of people Tuesday after the presentations, I need to do this in a more public forum so I will feel better and maybe evoke some change for the next time this class is taught.
As one of the last people to present on a long (long) night of presenters, I felt incredibly uncomfortable. Each person before me, excepting a few, flagrantly disregarded the time limit imposed on each presentation (8 minutes, was it?). Some topics were as long as twenty minutes. And as the night wore on, I felt like people were anxious and ready to leave, though not everyone had shared. So, by the time I presented, the entire class was gathered, waiting to leave. Apprehension and pressure from the class was expected, but it practically palpable. My presentation, including my short blurb on my website, lasted five minutes. If that. In relative comparison with others, I was definitely cut short by an unanimous decision by the group to leave as soon as possible.
I know that everyone wanted to share EVERYTHING that s/he had done this semester, but if there is a time limit, it should be enforced, so not to slight anyone at the end. I had planned to share more, but felt if I had, people might have resented my using more of their time, and yet, others had done the very same thing earlier in the night.
If anything can be learned from this situation, and I have to believe that each problem in life presents us with lessons to learn from, presentations need ENFORCED time limits. A timer, or an accurate watch would do. Rather than have people feel slighted or pressured, it would be best in future to have more structure, and more time, at the end of the semester for presentations that are worth so much, both for the course, and for each of us personally.
** On a positive note, I really wished I could have seen EVERYONE's presentations!!
9 comments:
I was severely disappointed that you didn't have more time to present, since yours was one of the presentations I was most looking forward to. I must admit, I was more than ready to leave by the time you went, but it was so interesting that once your movie started rolling, I forgot about wanting to leave. Honestly. Larissa and I both thought that a project like yours would be great in the classroom and looks really fun as well. I will definitely assign something like this in the future. Here's to a job well done...
Thanks Nat. I REALLY appreciate it! Hopefully I can share some positive reactions from the Evergreen students after I student teach there; this unit should be fun!
Dawn
Dawn, I apologize for both Alex and me.
I agree completely with everything you say here. And your saying it makes me feel even worse than I already felt Tues night about your (and our) having to rush your work at the end.
I felt that we were in a trap of our own making this semester. This was a large class--even just 7 more people than the cap for grad classes often felt like many many more to me. I never felt that I had adequate time for individuals.
We definitely needed two class nights for presentations. Even with two class nights we would still have had to split the class to do the presentations justice.
Now I am sorry we didn't meet the previous week for those presenters who were ready and wanted to go on the 5th.
Actually the last 1/4 at least of the semester should have been delegated to project presentations.
Please accept my apologies. I think your work on this topic is wonderful. I did feel folks were anxious to leave--understandably of course.
But I would have stayed till as long as it took if I had felt there were a more receptive audience for that.
And I know many people would have stayed--uncomplainingly.
Know though that the work you have produced is for yourself -- your own learning. I found that a difficult thing to accept about my job as teacher.
I worked so hard to do what I thought were amazing things at times and there was never an audience--my students of course--although they were too young to really get the work that went into what I was doing.
Much of the work of teaching is like that. You won't have an audience and often surely not an appreciative one.
I did learn from the presentations on Tues. not to try to repeat this situation next semester.
One of the difficulties in our class was that we had unlimited expectations and limited time.
I hope you understand and I hope that you accept my apology. I hope it does help to know how I was feeling on Tues. night about anyone's having to rush her/his presentation.
I am glad most of the class got out afterwards. That was nice for me. And I did make a point of talking with Erik. I hope you noticed that.
He was very patient with us and for him as well I was disappointed that you didn't have more time.
I want very much to see what you did with the other two poems. Right now I have a stack of reflections, CD's, and a huge pile of 374 folders so forgive me for asking a question I should already know the answer to--is the work online? Or do you have a disk for me?
Though you only had a short time to present, your idea and presentation had a great impact. I truly think your idea has significant use in the classroom. We don't have iMovie, but I am already working on adapating your idea to power point. Great job, Dawn and thanks for the inspiration!
Dawn - Your "pixel poetry" was so moving. I truly believe that if poetry is presented in this fashion to students, or if they are given the ability to create their own pixel poetry, they would be truly engaged. Thanks for sharing your work with us!
Chrissy G
Thanks, everyone!
Dawn, I know we already spoke about this very issue on Tuesday night. I just wanted to re-emphasize my sympathy to you (and anyone else who felt rushed)because I was witness to the time you've invested in this project. What a wonderful fact, though, that you've completed so much on this creative topic that you will be able to use in the near future! I am sorry you did not get the opportunity to share more of your work. BUT, had people been more on schedule then those of us from across the hall would not have seen ANY of your project at all. So, in a way -- we win!
Dawn, I totally agree with you about the time lapse at the end. Because we had no speakers in the MAC lab, I too felt pushed out of the way. I tried to be understanding, but after listening and commenting on everyone else's projects thoughtfully, I was dissapointed that mine was rushed and that I didn't have time to discuss why I choose to do the visual poetry project. Also, I was simply worn out by the end and my excitement was gone.
Anyways, I just wanted to tell you that I loved the outcome of your visual poetry project, and that even though the night was rushed, I was very happy that I got a chance to watch yours and see the differences between our projects. I share your frustration, even though I didn't create a website in addition like you did, and I just wanted to tell you that you did a wonderful job!!!!
I wish someone commenting here after me had at least acknowledged my post.
Post a Comment